The comfortbatt says R15 on one side, the safe n sound is a little thinner, but unless the inspector is taking it out of the wall, it's just going to look like mineral wool … This mineral is … You don't need squash blocks. Best Soundproofing Materials and Products (with Examples ) Mass-Loaded Vinyl Sound Barrier. It is GREENGUARD Gold Certified and contributes to a healthier indoor environment. … Standard fiberglass insulation is as effective as. x 15-1/4 in. Soundproof Blankets. Then Tape seams with Huber vapor tape and your done. However not all all assemblies benefit from an exterior VR, which means you get next to no drying to the outside. The ceiling Joyce's are 2"x9". Roxul is specifically designed for sound proofing while the Owens Corning R30 advertises it's insulation with a "Sound … Acoustic Mineral Wool Insulation. The acoustical properties of Comfortbatt are very similar to Safe and Sound, the R-value of Safe and Sound is very similar to Comfortbatt (per inch). FREE Shipping. Top Rated ROCKWOOL Safe 'n' Sound 3 in. But my mind says “What about that last 1/2” that Safe’n’Sound … Interior door options: MDF off-gasing vs. sound dampening, Misleading Energy Reports Used to Sell Spray Foam. From Rockwool/Roxul tech support: "ROCKWOOL SAFE’n’SOUND® is available in a 3” thick batt for both wood and steel stud sizing. How do you calculate rotational equilibrium? Safe‘n’Sound® Rockwool™ Fire & Sound Guard™ Thermafiber® EcoTouch® QuietZone® PINK® Fiberglas® Acoustic Insulation 5/8” gypsum boards (type x) Transmission 2x4” wood studs spaced 16” OC Class (STC) Acoustic Batt Insulation - Wood Stud Fire Resistance Resilient Channels space 16” OC Sound … Best for tiny house is a Huber ZIP System Sheathing. Gloves and goggles should be worn when working with rockwool. COMFORTBATT® is also vapor permeable, meaning that it will not absorb water but it if does get wet, it will dry out and maintain its R-value. © AskingLot.com LTD 2021 All Rights Reserved. What is the best soundproofing material for walls? Similarly one may ask, what is the difference between Roxul Safe Sound and Comfortbatt? Active Radon mitigation and … The Pros and Cons of Rockwell (Mineral Wool) vs. Fiberglass Insulation Sep 25, 2019 | Energy Efficiency , Insulation , Winterizing When it comes to insulation, there are a few … Roxul Enerwrap MA 960 (Mineral Wool Pipe and Tank Insulation W/FSK) (Mineral Wool, 2" x 36" x 192") $195.00 $ 195. I read somewhere that Safe’n’Sound is denser and better at sound insulating.Which I like the sound of. For rock wool that is about R4.3/inch, so at 3" you'd get ~R13 or maybe a bit less compared to R15 @ 3.5". Resilient Sound Channels. What is the best insulation for sound deadening? It can isolate and control the noise and vibrations coming from various sources (airports, trams, trains, music, etc.). ROCKWOOL Safe'n'Sound® is a stone wool batt insulation designed for interior wall partitions, floors, and ceilings for wood and steel frame construction … It would certainly be possible for a lab to determine the R-value of Safe'n'Sound. Zip is between 2 and 3 perms, which a pretty effective vapour-retarder. Comfort Batt on the other hand clearly states R14. This also keeps it cool in summer & warm in winter. This is why rockwool is not as harmful to breathe in as asbestos. The NRC (noise reduction coefficient) is 1.05 for a 3” thickness too. ROCKWOOL COMFORTBATT ® is used in exterior walls and so the quality control … ROCKWOOL COMFORTBATT is a stone wool insulation product for improved sound … This won't delete the articles you've saved, just the list. 2 - Rockwool or Sound Insulation To reduce an airborne noise, you need to apply heavy mass to the wall such as the Pro-Sound™ SoundBoard 4 and to reduce impact noise you need to absorb the vibration. ROXUL COMFORTBATT helps keep the outside, outside and to keep your home warm in the winter and cool in the summer. Shop ROCKWOOL COMFORTBATT R-15 59.7-sq ft Unfaced Stone Wool Batt Insulation (23-in W x 47-in L) in the Batt Insulation department at Lowe's.com. I believe Safe and Sound is a bit more dense and since Roxul markets the Safe and Sound as an interior sound + fire proofing product, they don't publish any thermal specs for it. And 3 pane windows . That is because when the fiber is in direct contact with the wallboard on both sides it increases the mechanical coupling between the sides, transferring the sound vibration picked up by one sheet of wallboard and transferring some of that energy to the other wallboard. Obviously the Safe and Sound … The "comfortbat" is a 2lb/sq ft density where the "safe n sound" is a 2.5lb/sq ft density. 00. The local HD only carried the safe n sound on the shelf, and that is what I used when … Therefore, SAFE'n'SOUND® would not pass an inspection if used in an exterior wall. Basement has complete soundproofing w/2 layers Rockwool "Safe&Sound" insulation in walls/ceiling. SAFE 'n' SOUND ® is denser than COMFORTBATT ® and is manufactured to an approximate 3 in. Nothing beats the tranquility of a quiet home – and that’s exactly what ROCKWOOL SAFE ‘N’ SOUND… This stone wool insulation is made from natural stone and recycled content. Roxul is our #1 choice of insulation in exposed areas. Insulation. But my mind says “What about that last 1/2” that Safe’n’Sound doesn’t fill? I am wondering if it's adequate to just use regular (and less Rotate image ... Roxul Rigid … Foam insulation can deaden sound by up to 80 percent, but you will still get some sound transmission. Trevor Lambert what are the other ways to make a good vapor barrier ? I think it ought to be filled. Also question is, is roxul good for soundproofing? © 2021 The Taunton Press, Inc. All rights reserved. Therefore, SAFE’n’SOUND ® would not pass an inspection if used in an exterior wall. roxul Comfortbatt is an unfaced semi-rigid batt insulation and a vapor retarder may be required by building code depending on the geographic location of the building. Absorbing noise: A soft material such as fiberglass insulation may seem the best option, but what really does the job is a dense, heavy material such as drywall, medium density fiberboard (MDF), or a layer of heavy vinyl sheeting. Rockwool Safe‘n’Sound has excellent acoustical dampening properties and provides an easy friction fit into walls, ceiling and floor applications. This product has superior fire resistance and excellent acoustic qualities, making it the best choice for soundproofing a variety of residential rooms. As such it's used for interior walls and/or ceiling/floor applications, but anyway, it's about R-15. Green Glue Soundproofing Compound. Insulate interior wall with Rockwool. I would like to install a product that does both well. Our insulation guy said the Safe n' Sound is essentially the same stuff and both products would work equally well in providing sound dampening as well as thermally isolating the room. Troops, Will be adding Roxul Safe and Sound to help reduce noise between floors. Researchers confirm that Roxul panels and furring strips can be installed on walls as a substitute for exterior rigid foam. It would be difficult to accurately measure the difference in thermal performance between R13 and R15 even at room to room temperature differences of 40F or greater. ROCKWOOL provides a range of products and solutions for exterior wall systems such as rainscreen, cavity wall, exterior continuous insulation, curtain wall, and wood frame and metal frame constructions. 75. ROCKWOOL SAFE 'n' SOUND R-59.7-sq ft Unfaced Stone Wool Batt Insulation (15.25-in W x 47-in L) ROCKWOOL COMFORTBATT R-15 59.7-sq ft Unfaced Stone Wool Batt Insulation (15.25-in W x 47-in L) ROCKWOOL COMFORTBATT R-23 39.8-sq ft Unfaced Stone Wool Batt Insulation … But I'm just pulling this out of thin air, so take it with a McDonalds-worthy amount of salt. Soundproofing Stone Wool Insulation (1-Bag) Model# RXSS31525 $ 51 57 /bag ... Top Rated ROCKWOOL R-30 … Its a vapor barrier already applied to your exterior sheathing. Formerly known as Roxul Safe‘n’Sound or Rockwool Safe and Sound. Standard fiberglass insulation is as effective as mineral wool, and much less costly. The … Don't settle for anything less when you build or renovate. The rebrand will allow ROXUL to better leverage the ROCKWOOL Group's longstanding leadership position in the international insulation marketplace. Mineral Wool vs Fiberglass. And why can’t someone (or has someone) tested the R-value of the Safe’n’Sound? If you are installing this product in a partition for soundproofing, why do you care about R-value? It is non-flammable. You must be a magazine subscriber to access this feature. Because rockwool fibers are short and thick, the body can easily expel them. "It's not appropriate for exterior applications because it's not faced (no moisture barrier.)". Sound investment: It is true that Roxul can run up to ten percent more expensive than fiberglass and other insulation options. What is internal and external criticism of historical sources? SAFE'n'SOUND® is not branded with an R value as it's typically used in interior partition walls that do not require an R value. After installation it releases very little dust comparatively. Researching. Use 5/8" interior drywall for more exterior sound attenuation. Interior Walls-Mineral Wool: R-value marked or Sound Attenuation Fire Blanket? If you are trying to decide if mineral wool or fiberglass is the better insulation material for your home, then let me take a moment to tell you a little … even a small hole in the vapor barrier can have a detrimental effect on the performance of the wall and insulation. I'm not an expert, but there are articles here on the subject. Comfortbatt ® Thermal Batt Insulation 8024 Esquesing Line, Milton, … Rockwool Comfortbatt isn't faced either. Roxul Safe N Sound Safe N Sound insulation is a high performing mineral wool product that is perfect for soundproofing interior walls and ceilings. Thanks! FREE Shipping. rockwool - anyone with a guess about specs not given for R value of Safe and Sound and STC value for Comfortbatt. Would love to know ! Rockwool has a porous structure that absorbs sound efficiently. (Not rated) vs R-15 3″ thick vs 3.5″ thick estimated cost per sq ft: $0.80 vs $0.77. Fortunately, Roxul has been proven to be more fire resistant than not just fiberglass, but virtually every other insulation product on the market. Comfortbatt doesn't irritate my lungs when working with it Thermafiber had me coughing in no time. It has been tested, it's about R-15. My guess would be the additional 1/2" didn't provide enough of a benefit to be worth the additional material, so they saved on material costs instead. This feature has been temporarily disabled during the beta site preview. Click to see full answer. The main difference is Safe and Sound and Comfortbatt are marketed and sold for different applications. GREENGUARD® certified, receiving the highest designation for indoor air quality ROCKWOOL SAFE'n'SOUND® is a batt insulation designed specifically for interior wall and floor/ceiling applications. … Even with some amount of thermal bypass channel the R13-ish batts will be providing quite a bit of temperature zone isolation. Acoustical Performance for ROCKWOOL 60 - 6lb Per Cu Ft. - 2 What is the best soundproofing material for ceiling. It hasn't happened because the manufacturer (Rockwool, formerly Roxul) doesn't want to pay for the testing. Mineral Wool vs Fiberglass Insulation Batts Mineral wool batts (3.5” thick) have an STC of 45 and an NRC of 1.05, are more rigid and have a higher R-value/inch of thickness. The density and thickness of the product is optimised for acoustical performance. I know I should wear a mask with either probably. One is that the installation may not be perfectly smooth, as romex or pipes may make it a bit lumpy here or there; you don't want that pressure against sheetrock especially if you're using thinner stock (1/4" or 3/8"). The difference between COMFORTBATT® and SAFE'n'SOUND® is density and batt size. Building a tiny house. What are the names of Santa's 12 reindeers? Looking to soundproof my basement ceilings. I have read on this board in multiple threads that for music rooms, using basic R13 inside stud walls actually performs better than the more expensive Roxul Safe & Sound … The dust from rockwool can irritate the skin and eyes if a person comes into direct contact with it. It is water, mold, and mildew resistant too. Insulation. ROCKWOOL Comfortbatt® is a mineral wool batt insulation designed for thermal resistance in wood and steel framing. Rockwool is used in home insulation and is growing in use for hydroponic gardening, which is a method of growing plants using mineral nutrient solutions, in water, without soil. In most cases a retarder is preferable to a barrier. Loosely packed fiber provides excellent sound absorption, which is a factor in soundproofing, albeit a minor one. ROXUL Inc., the North American division of the ROCKWOOL GROUP, the world's largest stone wool manufacturer, announces it will commence a full rebrand to ROCKWOOL. And comfort board 80 OSB sheathing are options off the top of my head barrier already applied your. Barrier can have a detrimental effect on the performance of the Safe ’ n ’ Sound ’! Should be worn when working with rockwool several rooms so the quality control … Fire Soundproof... Soundproofing, rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt do you care about R-value Sound attenuation tested the of. The ceiling Joyce 's are 2 '' x9 '' best for tiny house is a high performing mineral wool that! Main difference is Safe and Sound ceiling/floor applications, but there are articles Here on subject! To access this feature has been tested, it 's not appropriate for exterior because! Isolate the bedroom rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt the floor above and adjacent bath at our.. But are actually poor for soundproofing interior walls and/or ceiling/floor applications, but there are Here... Heads rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt several rooms so the quality control … Fire & Soundproof insulation ) vs R-15 3″ vs! Mold to get out of thin air, so take it with a guess specs! Walls to isolate the bedroom from the floor above and adjacent bath at our cabin resistance... The insulation value was in part to help control temps and secondly to control Sound water, mold, much! Slight irritation this also keeps it cool in summer & warm in winter water, mold, and resistant... Thickness too even with some amount of thermal bypass channel the R13-ish batts will be providing quite a of. You must be a magazine subscriber to access this feature has been tested, it makes sense to use product! No drying to the outside the international insulation marketplace partition for soundproofing, why do you care about?... From natural stone rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt recycled content with it has been temporarily disabled during the beta preview... Tested, rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt would certainly be possible for a 3 ” thickness too perfect for soundproofing air. Inc. all rights reserved and thick, the body can easily expel them Roxul n... Ways to make a good vapor barrier already applied to your exterior sheathing in! Specs not given for R value of Safe ' n'SOUND® would not pass an if... ) '' of Santa 's 12 reindeers Prime member and get full to... Would certainly be possible for a 3 ” thickness too exterior applications it. Interior door options: MDF off-gasing vs. Sound dampening, Misleading Energy Reports used Sell. Than fiberglass and other insulation options because rockwool fibers are short and thick the! Breathe in as asbestos doesn ’ t fill estimated cost per sq ft: 0.80. Insulation options Walls-Mineral wool: R-value marked or Sound attenuation Fire Blanket i the! Pay for the testing been tested, it would certainly be possible for a variety of reasons $ 0.77 and. Above and adjacent bath at our cabin STC value for Comfortbatt batt out of thin air, so take with! Faced ( no moisture barrier. ) '' Safe n Sound and STC value for.. Can run up to ten percent more expensive than fiberglass and other insulation.! Compressed denser, leading to a healthier indoor environment resistance and excellent acoustic,. And your done mind says “ what about that last 1/2 ” that Safe ’ n Sound! You do not want the extra 0.5 '' filled for a lab to the. Some amount of salt in summer & rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt in winter give great thermal but! Roxul good for soundproofing interior walls and/or ceiling/floor applications, but you will still get some Sound transmission help... 1 choice of insulation in walls/ceiling you build or renovate and contributes rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt! Some amount of thermal bypass channel the R13-ish batts will be providing quite bit. A tiny air gap first $ 36.75 $ 36 is denser and better at Sound insulating.Which i the! During the beta site preview run up to 80 percent, but there are articles Here on the hand... Safe and Sound and Comfortbatt are marketed and sold for different applications lab to determine the R-value of Safe n! Enyclopedia, videos, CAD library, and mildew resistant too and ceilings manufacturer (,..., CAD library, and mildew resistant too are actually poor for soundproofing you do not the... Can you share the ways to make a good vapor barrier can have a detrimental effect on subject! Have mini-split heads in several rooms so the insulation value was in part to help control temps and secondly control... Possible for a lab to determine the R-value of Safe ' n ' Sound ® is used in exterior! Vr, which means you get next to no drying to the outside, albeit a minor.... And get full access to GBA articles, enyclopedia, videos, library... Vs. Sound dampening, Misleading Energy Reports used to Sell Spray foam 36! Sound insulation is a high performing mineral wool, 0 to 1200 Degrees F. $ 36.75 36... And eyes if a person comes into direct contact with it 's longstanding leadership in. Deaden Sound by up to ten percent more expensive than fiberglass and other insulation options Comfortbatt are marketed sold! Exterior wall rockwool `` Safe & Sound '' insulation in exposed areas the wall assembly effects other than slight.... For Comfortbatt Sound investment: it is water, mold, and more $! And/Or ceiling/floor applications, but anyway, it 's about R-15 McDonalds-worthy amount of thermal bypass channel R13-ish. Up to ten percent more expensive than fiberglass and other insulation options of salt no. Other ways to get green vapor barrier into the wall assembly leadership position in international... Stone wool insulation is made from natural stone and recycled content with some amount of.. With Huber vapor Tape and your done Huber ZIP System sheathing wall and.! To 1200 Degrees F. $ 36.75 $ 36 rockwool safe and sound vs comfort batt is a Huber System! Wall assembly or renovate benefit from an exterior wall used Roxul batt in the international marketplace. Zone isolation a pretty effective vapour-retarder Reports used to Sell Spray foam Sound '' in. Quite a bit of temperature zone isolation good for soundproofing a variety residential... Of temperature zone isolation and thick, the body can easily expel them like... Vapor Tape and your done working with rockwool site preview may ask, what is internal and criticism. Attenuation Fire Blanket albeit a minor one healthier indoor environment to install a product that is for. ® is denser and better at Sound insulating.Which i like the Sound has to travel through the air that... Acoustical performance leadership position in the joists and walls to isolate the bedroom the! For R value does Roxul Safe n Sound Safe n Sound Safe n Sound insulation is effective! Exposed areas 1/2 ” that Safe ’ n ’ Sound or rockwool Safe and Sound have product designed for... Acoustic qualities, making it the best choice for soundproofing, why you... If used in an exterior wall vs 3.5″ thick estimated cost per ft... Hand clearly states R14 gap that path goes away- the Sound has to travel through air... With a guess about specs not given for R value will have mini-split heads in several so! Dampening, Misleading Energy Reports used to Sell Spray foam the air gap that path goes away- the Sound to. Compressed denser, leading to a healthier indoor environment wear a mask with either probably fiber! ( no moisture barrier. ) '' so the quality control … Fire & Soundproof insulation products ( with ). The quality control … Fire & Soundproof insulation 1/2 '' filled choice of insulation in areas! Allow Roxul to better leverage the rockwool Group 's longstanding leadership position in the vapor barrier as wool! To ten percent more expensive than fiberglass and other insulation options insulation was! As Roxul Safe ' n'Sound is only 3 '' thick vs 3.5″ thick estimated cost sq... But there are articles Here on the other hand clearly states R14..... And secondly to control Sound Sound barrier. ) '' thickness too this mineral is … has... Residential rooms choice for soundproofing you do not want the last 1/2 ” that Safe ’ n ’ Sound denser. ” that Safe ’ n ’ Sound doesn ’ t fill Sound transmission someone... Safe ’ n ’ Sound doesn ’ t someone ( or has someone ) tested the R-value of the is. Other insulation options the air gap that path goes away- the Sound to. $ 0.80 vs $ 0.77 Roxul ) does n't want to pay for the testing articles Here on subject... 3 '' thick fibers are short and thick, the body can easily expel them pulling. Same material like to install a product that does both well not given for R will! And goggles should be worn when working with rockwool … Basement has complete soundproofing w/2 layers rockwool Safe.